Gray Brothers Cafeteria Menu

Located in Mooresville, IN, Gray Brothers Cafeteria offers a wide range of American cuisine with a focus on comfort food favorites. This cafeteria-style restaurant provides a casual yet classy dining experience, perfect for lunch or dinner. With options for delivery, takeout, and reservation, Gray Brothers caters to various dining preferences.

The menu boasts an array of dishes, including fresh yeast rolls, blueberry muffins, chef salad, and daily vegetable specials like green beans and mashed potatoes. Customers have raved about the tasty and filling meals, with highlights such as fried chicken, au gratin potatoes, and cherry pie.

The cozy ambiance with multiple fireplaces, friendly service, and extensive food selection make Gray Brothers a nostalgic favorite for many. Whether you're looking for a hearty meal or just craving some comfort food, this cafeteria-style eatery is sure to satisfy your cravings.

Rolls/Muffins

Fresh Yeast Rolls

$1.05

Blueberry Muffins

$1.05

Corn Bread Muffins

$1.05

Chef Salad

$6.65

Pickled Beets

$2.50

Bean Salad

$2.50

Cubed Jello

$2.50

Applessauce

$2.50

Cottage Cheese

$2.50

Deviled Eggs

$2.50

Cranberry Jello

$2.50

Coleslaw

$2.50

Salads & Items

Daily Vegetables

Green Beans

$2.85

Buttered Corn

$2.85

Broccoli & Cauliflower

$2.85

Macaroni & Cheese

$2.50

Mashed Potatoes

$2.85

Harvard Beets

$2.85

Dressing

$2.41

Beets

$2.85

Broccoli/Cauliflower Mix

$2.85

Corn Casserole

$2.85

Breaded Tomatoes

$2.85

Roast Beef (Half)

$4.99

Roast Beef (Whole)

$8.99

Roast Beef Manhattan(Half)

$5.75

Roast Beef Manhattans(Whole)

$9.99

Fried White Chicken-Full

$5.85

Chicken Tenders

$5.40

Homemade Chicken & Noodles - Half

$3.20

Meatloaf - Half Order

$4.25

Meatloaf - Full Order

$7.25

Fried Chicken Livers- Full

$6.90

Swiss Steak

$6.99

Homemade Chicken & Noodles - Full

$6.25

Fried Chicken 1 Piece Thigh

$1.50

Fried Chicken Dark Meat 3 Pieces

$5.25

Fried Chicken 1 Piece Leg

$1.50

Homemade Beef & Noodles- Half

$3.20

Homemade Beef & Noodles-Full

$6.25

Breaded Baked Tilapia - 2 Pieces

$6.99

Breaded Baked Tilapia - 1/2 Piece

$3.80

Fried Salmon Patties

$5.99

Roasted Barbecue Chicken w/ Rice

$8.99

Dark Chicken

$1.50

Baked Cod - Full order

$8.85

Baked Cod - Half order

$4.50

Roast Pork with Dressing

$6.99

Fried Chicken

$1.45

Fried Chicken Livers - Half

$3.20

Ham & Beans with cornbread

$6.99

Daily Meat Selections

Dessert Fruit Pies

Apple Fruit Pie - Whole

$16.25

Apple Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.99

Apricot Fruit Pie - Whole

$16.25

Apricot Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.99

Cherry Fruit Pie - Whole

$16.25

Cherry Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.99

Fruit & Cream Slices

$3.65

Peach Cobbler - Regular

$33.00

Peach Cobbler - Per Order

$4.25

Pecan Slice

$4.45

Pumpkin Fruit Pie - Whole

$18.99

Pumpkin Fruit Pie - Slice

$4.45

Pumpkin Slice

$4.30

Raisin Fruit Pie - Whole

$16.25

Raisin Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.99

Sugar Free Apple Fruit Pie - Whole

$15.25

Sugar Free Apple Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.99

Peach Cobbler Serving

$4.35

Blackberry Fruit Pie - Whole

$16.25

Blackberry Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.95

Blackberry Slice

$3.85

Rhubarb - Whole

$16.25

Rhubarb - Slice

$3.99

Sugar Free Cherry Fruit Pie - Whole

$15.25

Sugar Free Cherry Fruit Pie - Slice

$3.99

Pecan Fruit Pie - Whole

$18.99

Pecan Fruit Pie - Slice

$4.45

Banana Cream Pie - Whole

$16.25

Banana Cream Pie - Slice

$3.99

Butterscotch Cream Pie - Whole

$16.25

Butterscotch Cream Pie - Slice

$3.99

Coconut Cream Pie - Whole

$16.25

Coconut Cream Pie - Slice

$3.99

Lemon Cream Pie - Whole

$16.25

Lemon Cream Pie - Slice

$3.99

Dessert Cream Pies

Dessert Frozen Fruit Pies

Frozen Apple Pie

$13.99

Frozen Apricot Pie

$13.99

Frozen Blackberry Pie

$13.99

Frozen Cherry Pie

$13.99

Frozen Pecan Pie

$13.99

Frozen Pumpkin Pie - Regular

$13.99

Frozen Pumpkin Pie - Slice

$4.30

Frozen Raisin Pie

$13.99

Frozen Sugar Free Apple Pie

$13.99

Frozen Sugar Free Cherry Pie

$13.99

Carrot Cake

$4.45

Chocolate Cake

$4.45

Peanut Butter Cake

$4.45

Tuxedo Cake

$4.45

Cheesecake

$4.35

Dessert Cakes

Drinks

Fountain Drinks

$2.10

20 Oz. Bottles

$2.00

1 Gallon of Tea

$4.25